Henckels, Messermeister, Güde, or Mercer. Henckels and Wusthof.While Messermeister is not as familiar a name as Henckels and Wusthof… My friend gave us a Wusthof classic ikon santoku as a wedding present and I really like it. Shun vs. Wusthof – Which Chef’s Knife Makes the Better Choice? David Olkovetsky, founder and CEO of Artisan Revere, told me over email that the reasons for the price tag are manifold: most importantly, the high-quality steel is made with more environmentally friendly methods, and the so-called "super steel" will retain its edge better than competitors. It stood edge-to-edge on sharpness with some of the more expensive knives. After extended periods of use, the metal handle became slippery and greasy in our hands. They use the same X50CrMo V15 steel that Wusthof and Henckel … Related Articles. Status Not open for further replies. However, we believe that in this Shun vs. Wusthof battle, Wusthof takes the gold. For $50, J.A. It performed well on most of our tests, struggling a little with the squash, but the sharp out-of-the-box edge quickly dulls with use. It's one of the weightiest knives I tested, which helps it slice more delicate foods such as tomatoes as effortlessly as warm butter and cut through more robust foods like butternut squash without much exertion. Comparing the Wusthof vs. Henckels will probably take days until you understand all the small and minimalistic differences between the brands. Make carving that holiday ham so much easier. Of these knives, three were the clear leaders, most others were solidly designed and only one stood out as really bad. Henckels and Wusthof.While Messermeister is not as familiar a name as Henckels and Wusthof… Henckels knives have a value of 57. Personally would go with the messermeister… Order by December 15th for On-Time Christmas Delivery. That makes almost every type of prep, from slicing and dicing to mincing and chicken boning, feel awkward at best and dangerous at worst. Hardness Rating. Henckels International Classic 8" Chef's Knife (31161-201), Credit: Reviewed.com / Lindsay D. Mattison, 7 tips for staying safe during space heater season. Wusthof's 8-inch classic chef's knife is a workhorse in the kitchen. For $50, J.A. Yoshihiro Vs Shun: Comparison Of Two Japanese Brands . What is the Best Affordable, Best Inexpensive, Best Cheap Brands to Buy. Not only is the Mac super sharp (it slides through tomatoes without any tearing whatsoever), but its blade is thinner than heavier knives like Wusthof's, which makes slicing snappier veggies like carrots feel like cutting a ripe banana with a butter knife. This high-carbon steel German … Mercer Vs Victorinox: In Search Of An Excellent Knife. Wusthof vs. Zwilling J.A. This is a sharp knife that performed well on most tasks, taking down heavy-duty items with no problems but struggling ever-so-slightly on precision work like tackling tomato skin without snagging and thinly slicing radishes. Plus Free Shipping. I thought this lighter knife would struggle to tackle the heavy-duty tasks, but it sliced through butternut squash like it was a soft stick of butter. Henckels' Zwilling Gourmet 8-inch Chef's knife is a great budget option. Knife Blades: Wusthof vs. Henckels. While it had great balance and control and was sharp enough to perform well on precision tasks, it struggled with heavy-duty tasks because it simply was not heavy enough to accomplish them. Since you're going to be using it a lot, a chef's knife should be a pleasure to use -- properly weighted, but not heavy enough to make using it tiring. While most of the blades from Henckels and Wusthof look relatively similar to each other, there are some distinctions. It's also lighter, which means your hand won't be guided quite as well through a tomato or similarly delicate food. Hi, I’m Lindsay Mattison, a trained professional chef. A good knife can feel like a dream -- and it can make holiday cooking even more fun than usual -- but a poorly balanced or dull one can be a pain to use, and can even lead to more cut fingers and other accidents. The Wusthof Classic I think loses out on all points to a Messermeister, but they do have the Ikon line that is a little more impressive. Luckily, I've tested some of the most popular chef's knives on the market, and below are the best chef knife picks for every kind of home cook. They're also the perfect tool for cutting a large steak or prepping vegetables due to their straight, rigid blades. The Henckels Zwilling Pro is a serious workhorse, pulling ahead of the pack in nearly every one of our tests and earning the top spot as Best Overall Chef’s Knife. However, that comes from working in kitchens, where we do so much more volume and the wusthof didn't have the edge retention of other knives. These hybrid knives take hard Japanese steel and forge them to be all-purpose like traditional Western chef’s knives, sharpening both sides of the blade. Wüsthof Classic Ikon 8" Cook's Knife (4596/20), Mercer Renaissance Collection 8" Forged Riveted Chef's Knife (M23510), Zwilling J.A. The Ikon line of Wusthof chef's knives have more of a contoured handle for an ergonomic grip, but in our testing, we found the handle to be a tad too long, which negatively affects its balance. Grab your cutting board and tomatoes -- we're diving in! Beyond its measurable performance with various foods, I approached each knife as a package -- experiencing how its weight and balance came together to create an experience that either felt intuitive or awkward. Frankly I have no idea about the performance difference between that and more expensive sigmaforges. i'm at work right now so i'd have to check on it. We've compiled a list of the Best Messermeister Vs Wusthof of 2019 to buy, including Top (Highest) Rated Messermeister Vs Wusthof Reviews on Amazon.com, eBay, Walmart, Best Buy, Reddit. Henckels forges their smaller blades up to 6", after which they are 'scintered' together out of three different steels (way high-tech). Henckels Global Calphalon Cangshan Chef'sChoice Cuisinart Epicurean John Boos & Co. KAI Kikuichi KitchenAid® Kyocera Laguiole en Aubrac Laguiole Jean Dubost Messermeister Michel Bras … Henckels Pro 12-Piece Knife Block Sets. Free shipping available on orders over $49. Surfas sells knives from Messermeister; the 10-inch chef's knife costs $144. The knives that will be considered for comparison are the Wüsthof and the Zwilling J.A. The blade itself was skinnier than most of the knives we tested, positioning my fingers closer to the blade than I wanted, and it lacked the finer control that a wider blade offers. Which one works best for you … Wüsthof is one of the leading manufacturers of chef's knives. Henckels Twin Pro S 7-Piece Knife Set. Made in . Here are the best chef's knives we tested ranked, in order: Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Its weight and balance made it easy to control when tackling both heavy-duty and precision tasks, and it was especially well-suited for dicing onions. In the end, it all boils down to personal preference. Zwilling J.A. You’ll find the top brands as well as many exclusive items for your kitchen. wusthof and henckels are probably equivalent mfrs. We are experts in cutlery, kitchen knives and cookware. Henckels knives, but unfortunately this knife missed the mark. Is a steam bath the secret to baking better bread? After owning a wusthof classic I feel like a messermeister would be the better choice. An affordable line of stamped knives. Henckels German made forged knives. The Wusthof Classic Ikon and the Wusthof Classic are great knives. just make sure you compare apples to apples. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read. While it was sharp enough to cut paper, it made jagged slices of tomatoes and bruised the delicate basil. The rest of my current set are Henckels chinese crap. A good chef’s knife should be able to tackle the majority of your knife work in the kitchen, so it needs to be well-rounded and capable of handling almost any task you can throw at it. Henckels International Fine Edge Synergy 17-pc Knife Block Set. It struggled on all of the tests and wasn’t sharp enough to make it through the tomato test. Plus, if you find it on sale for a cool $80, like I did, then you should absolutely snap up this lightweight kitchen knife. The one thing you should never do with a chef's knife is put it in your dishwasher. After all, peer reviews are a critical part of any scientific process. The handle is extremely light, which leaves the center of balance for the knife an inch or two down the blade. Segal, the Santa Monica knife maker, above, … This makes these knives stronger than the average Japanese knife—but with the same super-sharp blade designed to maintain its edge for a long time. The J. Whenever you’re looking for a great new kitchen knife, you never want something subpar that’ll falter after a few months. I wrote about knife sharpeners in a separate story. Its belly is also comfortably rounded, which makes the rocking motion while mincing feel natural. Key Players Mentioned in the Global Mezzaluna Knives Market Research Report: Wusthof, Dexter Russell, Victorinox, Williams Sonoma, Michel Bras, Robert Welch, Zwilling J. Amazon reviewers seemed to agree—the Victorinox has over 5,000 reviews with a 4.8-star rating. Mercer, Zwilling and to a lesser degree, offered solid performance and well-balanced products for beginners looking for a bargain (Victorinox gets a lot of love online for its price tag and balance, but it's more expensive than the $16 Mercer and not quite as well balanced). The design of the wide, tapered bolster made this knife easy to grip and seriously comfortable to use. Global's design is also unique: the handle and blade are made of a single piece of high-carbon steel, and the handle is filled with sand to weight it. You could keep buying those generic $10 knives from the store every time your knife gets dull, but if you're really serious about upping your kitchen game, a high-quality chef's knife is one of the best investments you can make. This is in the top two most expensive knives we tested, and while it’s a great overall performer, it didn't quite measure up to the Zwilling. While I gave my assessments above, everyone will have their own slight preferences -- Global feels best to me, but if I ate more meat and denser veggies, I would probably lean toward Wusthof as the more robust blade. This knife will require constant sharpening if you want to keep it sharp enough to slice tomatoes. Wusthof knives are harder and sturdier, but they’re also less flexible and sharp. In short, don't buy this knife. This Japanese-style chef's knife lies at the higher end of the spectrum when it comes to price, but it rests at the top of most best lists online for a reason: it's a fantastic product. Chef knives are usually made of either stainless steel or carbon steel. Thinner grinds, smaller handles, still nigh indestructible. Best Cyber Monday deals still available: AirPods, Amazon Echo, laptops and more, PS5 restock update: Check inventory at GameStop, Best Buy, Walmart, Amazon and Target, Best Buy flash sale: You've got 12 hours to score deals on Fitbit Versa 3, Theragun, earbuds and more, Discuss: Best chef's knives for 2020: Global, Zwilling, Wusthof and more, Mac Professional Series 8-inch Chef's Knife with Dimples, Mercer Culinary Millennia 8-inch Chef's Knife, The best rubs you can buy for grilled steak, chicken, pork and fish, The best direct-to-consumer kitchen knives in 2020: Made In, Material, Brigade, Aura and more, The best toaster oven is the one you'll hate the least, The best meal kit delivery services of 2020, Wine, beer, alcohol delivery: How to get alcoholic beverages delivered to your door, The best seafood delivery companies to order online for 2020, Instant Pot wine: Yes, you can make that during quarantine, too. The light weight and cheap design mean you don't get the long life or the full versatility you'd get from a workhorse like the Wusthof, but if you're wanting a starter chef's knife to learn for six months while you save for a bigger investment, the Mercer really is a great cook's knife. 1; 2; Next. You might even want an ergonomic handle. Mac's most popular chef knife is perfectly balanced, so you never feel at risk of losing control of the blade. Henckels has a hardness rating of 56-57 Rockwell, but on some collections designed by Bob Kramer (some are Japanese) is 61 Rockwell. With this in mind, we selected 15 knives from all price points to find their strengths and weaknesses, relying heavily on testing procedures instead of just personal preference. The weight gave it the strength to handle the heavy-duty tasks we threw at it, cutting through butternut squash with ease. No, I'm not exaggerating -- this is a super sharp knife. Hands-down, the biggest surprise of my testing was the performance of Mercer's $16 Culinary Millennia 8-inch chef's knife. All that said, the Zwilling's cuts were consistently clean, it felt comfortable in my hand, and for $50, I'd be more than happy to add this knife to my kitchen. Are there some differences? The hand forged blade has been ground down to a thin profile to create a razor sharp edge. Now available for online purchase! I've used the knife daily for a few weeks, along with subjecting it to the same tests as the other knives on this list, and the blade, though certainly dulling over time, has maintained its edge more effectively than other blades. Within a couple of months of regular use, I chipped off the tip of my Mac: I was holding the knife and turning when the tip nicked an open cupboard and simply broke off. We'll update this list periodically. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Next Last. It's in the top 3 bestselling knife sets and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as Wusthof Ikon Seven or Wusthof Gourmet 12. But it's a really well-designed middle child that will feel incredibly comfortable to many home cooks. A chef's knife can be your best friend in the kitchen -- if you find the right fit. That said, for german knives I prefer the Messermeister Elites to both Henckels and Wusthof… Apr 24, 2013 #1 So I'm looking to get some non-crap knives, finally. Henckels … This super-light knife had a beautiful, sleek look. Global's popular chef's knife is a Japanese-style blade, which means it boasts a scary-sharp edge and a nimble-feeling lightweight body. If you're not comfortable sharpening your own knife, you can always bring it to a professional. Be respectful, keep it civil and stay on topic. Hello all, I am trying to decide between the Messermeister Meridian Elité 16-Piece Knife Block Set and the Zwilling J.A. In this way, you can be sure which brand suits your style. So it is advisable to buy a stamped knife first from both the company. In this Henckels vs Wusthof post, we’ll look at the differences between these two knives, their similarities and finally end up listing their most prominent pros and cons. 1 10 Joined Nov 5, 2001 . A. Henckels, Shun, Kyocera, Messermeister, Chef’sChoice, Kikuichi, Global. Wüsthof knives and accessories are hand-crafted to perfection and designed with all uses in mind. Apr 23, 2007 4,153 0 1,180. Okay, not a professional chef, but the best chef your own kitchen has ever seen. If you’re looking for the best German kitchen knives, you can’t go wrong with Wusthof, Zwilling J.A.